This post has NO AI.
Beating both "headline" S&P GSCI (+3.7%) and Bloomberg (0.1%) commodity index ETFs, the Vista Basket closed at $1,222,577.03 up $183,831.65 on 12/31/2024 up 16% for the year.
This blog hopes to deliver interesting, valuable and timely Index, Market and Public Policy commentary. Focus is on answering questions, debunking myths, testing claims and helping people avoid financial disasters. NO AI IS USED IN THE CREATION OF THIS BLOG!
This post has NO AI.
Beating both "headline" S&P GSCI (+3.7%) and Bloomberg (0.1%) commodity index ETFs, the Vista Basket closed at $1,222,577.03 up $183,831.65 on 12/31/2024 up 16% for the year.
This post has no AI.
The S&P GSCI Commodity Index tracking exchange traded fund (ETF) symbol GTG, was up 8% in 2024. The Blomberg Commodity Index tracking ETF symbol DJP rose 5.5%. The DB Commodity Index ETF was down 3.5% in 2024, posting losses two years in a row. These are three of the oldest and largest commodity ETFs in the market.
The normalized perfrmance chart and return table are shown below. Note that GSG leads the other names early in the year and maintained its lead through year-end.
Bitcoin has the highest historic returns EVER in ANY market. It even eclipses the gains of AAPL, Google and Microsoft. Where does this price appreciation come from? Also, we see widespread adoption of bitcoin by major financial institutions in multiple forms (ETFs, swaps, futures). Does this mean we should invest in Bitcoin and its derivatives?
Below is a chart and table of GBTC and SPY, the largest bitcoin and S&P 500 ETFs since the inception of GBTC in 2015:
SPY
barely shows up on the chart. GBTC is the world’s
oldest and largest (last I looked) bitcoin ETF. There is a slew of new crypto
ETFs. While the above returns are out of this world, so are the risks! And
standard deviation 5 times greater than SPY does not capture it. There are
enormous one day losses GBTC can experience. Below is a scatter plot of daily
price changes for GBTC and SPY.
It may be hard to see but one-day 10% moves up or down are much greater for GBTC than SPY (84 days vs. 5 days). The worst day ever for GBTC was down 49% versus down 11% for SPY.
By definition, since nothing underlies crypto, it is a pure gamble.
Further, bitcoin and almost ALL crypto exist in a digital anonymous blockchain. Anonymity or “trustless value” is its major calling card and there’s the rub. Bitcoin deliberately has no “know your customer” (KYC).
KYC is the basis of modern finance and every financial institution including every casino (except bitcoin). KYC is a fundamental tenant of AML or anti-money laundering. With no KYC, bitcoin has unprecedented availability to and demand from money laundering, drug dealing and terrorism. This accounts for its fantastic rise in the marketplace. Many have called for outlawing bitcoin. Unlike legal porn (another source of outrageous return) which is shamed out of commerce, bitcoin has no shame, so far.
Ok, so if you own it, know WHAT you own!
Note
while bitcoin derivatives HAVE KYC, the underlying still doesn’t. The wrappers
don’t help. And while there is much work on decoding the blockchain (kind of
like decoding DNA) this will be slow to end crypto’s anonymity and source of
enormous demand.
-NO AI is used in writing this post!-
While I don't have the proof I believe there IS a proof of, what I call:
The Fundamental Theorem of Investing
Given any market that is 1-attributable, 2-non-opaque, 3-open, 4-free, 5-well formed, 6-where all participants are price takers, and 7-has positive skew (a long term history of rising prices); then,
A broad based index will outperform active management.
The proof, if it exists, may be something like this:
The broad based index is always long.
Any active manager must not always be long.
Any active manager must at times be flat or short.
Any active manager has costs and friction that long only investors do not.
Every flat position has zero return but can avoid long only losses.
Every short position has positive and negative return.
In axiom 7, a positive skew market, the weighted sum of upticks is greater than the sum of downticks.
Therefore, active managers can only beat the index if the sum of avoided downticks + "short downticks" is greater than all the ticks in the market-this may be a contradiction. Therefore the theorem holds. Ok, ok, as I said, this may not be a proof.
In other words, is the return of the flats and shorts enough to avoid the losses of long only and end up beating the long only return? It may be concievable but there is no "public" "audited" "freely available" evidence for this. Is there a fund, in history, that has done this? This is the unlikely prospect facing all active managers.
And "average" investors, with limited time, capital and no special access to information can easily WIN 70-90% of the time by just buying and holding the largest, lowest cost and most liquid investment in the world.
Caveat: a stock picker, anytime, can always hit the jackpot and beat the market but does it last? It's kind of like gambling as any long-term holder of Penn Central, Western Union, GE, US Steel, Ford, GM, IBM, Yahoo, AOL, Cisco and Intel (among many others) can tell you.
One last but major point: Indexing, as beneficial to investors as it may be, if it becomes the dominant investment theme in the market, will end up as a major systemic threat to the entire financial system. The system is based on the concept of rationing, of separating winners from losers and winnowing losers from the market. If too many investors never sell, well, we lose the system that picks winners from losers and that, if it ever happens, is a threat to the system.
S&P Global has just issued their 2024 first half SPIVA Scorecard which measures how many actively managed funds outperformed the S&P 500 across standard rolling time periods. Here are the results:
SPY Return & Percentage of All Large-Cap funds that underperformed the S&P 500®
Vista continues its rise and outperformance through the third quarter.
The Vista Commodity Basket of long-dated diversified commodity futures contracts extends it six-year rally up 10.5% for the year to date as of 8/31/2024. The compound annual growth rate for the past 5 years is 12.5%!
Since mid-July All TIME HIGHS the stock market has been in a whirlwind tour dropping almost 10% in 15 trading days and then a mixed recovery to today.
The Whirlwind chart shows how $100,000 invested in the major stock index ETFs would have fallen and recovered during this time period. The DOW! The much maligned Dow Jones Industrial Average as represenbted by DIA has fully recovered to its all time high!
In the first half of 2024, the Vista Commodity Basket rose 11% while the comparable GSCI and Bloomberg indexes were up only 9% to 3% for the same period.
Touted on LinkedIn: #ZFN #ETF units are up 22.6% Year to Date, compared with a gain of 13.92% for the S&P 500 Index
Normalized performance since inception (12/10/2018 = 1000 ): Not so much!
I don't get it! This fund is being touted on LinkedIn. WHO buys this underperforming stuff?
How many times do you have to prove it that paid managers cannot beat the S&P, let alone the QQQ??? Answer: Everytime!
While I admire Scott Galloway in many things, especially his "Prof G" and "Pivot" podcasts, I have questions about his personally touting/endorsing/selling the "Fundrise Flagship Fund".
What is this fund? It's an LLC! Well here it is direct from the chatbot on the Fundrise website:
"Fundrise is not listed on a public stock exchange; instead, it operates a platform for investing in shares of its funds, which are structured as REITs and are not publicly traded. If you're looking for a stock symbol for Fundrise itself, such a symbol does not exist because the company's funds are not traded on public markets."
Sorry Scott, touting private investments to unaccreddited investors is irresponsible. Unsophisticated investors have NO place in underperforming illiquid investments. Of course anyone can buy real estate and almost anything else directly themself. But does anyone need an illiquid, non-public LLC to charge fees and lose money? Terrible returning private Venture Cap funds are usually the purview of billionaires.
Since this is NOT a publicly traded fund, information is hard to get and IMHO misleading, at best. As the website says: These publicly registered [not publicly traded] funds are our largest and most diversified, and are akin to mutual funds of alternative assets.
Here's the best I could find from Fundrise.com:
Fundrise Real Estate Interval Fund, LLC
"During 2023, the Fund returned -11.79%, its third year of operations. During the same period the S&P 500® Total Return Index, a bellwether for the overall U.S. stock market, returned 26.29%..."
Fundrise Income Real Estate Fund, LLC
"The Fund returned 7.93% in 2023, its second year of operations. During the same period the S&P 500® Total Return Index, a bellwether for the overall U.S. stock market, returned 26.29%..."
Fundrise Growth Tech Fund, LLC
"...with the illiquid nature of the asset class... The Fund returned +1.53% during the year ended March 31, 2024. The Cambridge Associates LLC U.S. Venture Capital Index returned -2.53% in the third calendar quarter of 2023 and -0.47% in the second calendar quarter of 2023. The Fund returned 2.31% and -0.80% in those respective quarters."
Maybe this is not the big picture. From the Fundrise website itself , below may be the big picture (the SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust - SPY added by me):
Quick answer: they go flat or short. Either strategy is a loser. Why? The return of the S&P (and nearly ALL broad-based indexes) comes from a miniscule number of trading days that are very scattered and very unpredictable. The plot below shows the continuously compounded daily returns of SPY from its 1/29/1993 start date to 5/22/2024.
SPY has traded 7884 trading days or 31.28 years since inception. Here are the numbers:
CCROR = Continuously compounded rate of return (ln(day 2/day 1).
How to
Invest
An investment guide for everyone.
Investments
are a form of spending but spending on SAVINGS. Savings for yourself, your
future, your car, home, retirement, your family, your child or children’s
future.
Smart
investing involves knowing your needs and goals, researching and MAKING good
choices.
Needs and
Goals
We are
all unique. But while we all have some things in common: we each answer needs
in our own way. Investment needs depend upon your stage of life. Needs and
goals include your education, car, home, family, children’s education and
retirement and a slew of goals specific to each.
Take advantage of every wise
opportunity but most importantly, avoid bad choices. NO “for-profit” schools or
schools that advertise with promises. Go to community college if you must, use
school counseling, government and agency programs/grants for low/no income
students. Don’t sign student loan applications.
Buying a home may be the best INVESTMENT you can make. You not only INVEST your money but you LIVE in it and, as you pay down your mortgage, your home equity grows too! Mortgage payment is a form of forced saving and may be one of the best ways to accumulate wealth.
Index fund declines are a COST! A price you pay for superior FUTURE returns.
NEVER pay
fees for a financial planner or broker commissions. Forget buying stocks, commodities,
options and ESPECIALLY CRYPTO. These are all gambling. Don’t gamble until you
have substantial income and can AFFORD gambling losses.
When it
comes to insurance, buy only car and home insurance, and when you have dependents
buy ONLY straight life insurance. Insurance has huge commissions and is NOT an
investment.
Research
Your
library is your friend. Local, state and federal programs, agencies and
non-profit organizations can be lifelines. Learn and know your choices,
especially, what to avoid!
WHO you
invest with is as important as WHAT you invest in. Almost ALL financial
professionals offer products you don’t need, with unnecessary complexity and
with exorbitant, explicit or hidden fees. Throughout your financial life do not
be lured BY and avoid almost ALL full service advisors, insurance salesmen
(except when you NEED to insure your home, life or car) and stockbrokers.
Good
advice IS available but sadly without a good MBA one may not know what good
advice looks like. In my opinion, for those NOT in the know, only a few
investment firms truly exist to serve their customers: Vanguard and T Rowe
Price are the major companies that I recommend. Call them, tell them your
situation and they will give you excellent unembellished advice (no promises,
no misrepresentations).
BEWARE
ALL GET RICH QUICK SCHEMES. You already know this. As for bitcoin, the stock
market, house flipping, etc. etc. these are all forms of gambling and totally
depend upon your financial weight class. Choose wisely.
Investment
Choices
Just
like spending, you have choices. Different investments have different risks. Time
is your friend. Below is a table of investments ranked by risk, Risk is always
a subjective measure-subject to your personality and financial weight class. Time
is your friend and reduces your risk for retirement investments. Here’s one
standard way to rank investments by risk:
|
Investment |
Historical and Estimated Rates of
Return |
Risk |
|
Bank Savings |
0.1% to 3%, 1% |
Very low, FDIC insured |
|
Money Market Funds |
-1% to +2%, +3% on
average |
Very low |
|
Bond Funds |
-3% to +5%, +5% on
average |
Low |
|
Home Ownership |
-10% to +10%, +8% on
average |
Market risk |
|
Stock Market |
-20% to +20%, +8% on
average |
Market risk |
|
Technology Stocks |
-40% to +40%, 12% on
average |
Above Market |
|
Bitcoin |
-50% to +50%, no average |
Very high |
Stock
indexes have risen over time and this is the major
reason honest professionals recommend stock index investments for retirement
and long term investors. There is no guarantee this will continue! But,
for the last 200+ years, it has.
Stock
indexes are NOT favored by investment professionals due to their very low fees.
Some will lure you with no fees but offer to share in your profits. Again, at
Vanguard or TRP, you won’t have to give up very low fees.
Your
investment life is just one part of your money life, social and family life.
Make the most of what you have with your best possible choices.
Why Vanguard or T. Rowe
Price? I don’t work for them but in my experience, they are as good as it gets
for investors of all weight classes.. I suggest you call them and once you get
your bearings, then you can explore their websites. Their contact information
is:
Investor.vanguard.com
877-662-7447
troweprice.com 1-888-285-2612
Money markets have very low risk and are appropriate for
short term investments where you can’t afford losses such as for a car or down
payments.
Volatility is a fancy way
of measuring how much an investment has fallen in the past. It does not predict
how prices will move in the future.